Introduction
In the realm of email management, Authenticated Received Chain (ARC) sealing stands as a pivotal technique in ensuring the integrity and authenticity of electronic messages. Let's delve into this method, shedding light on its technical underpinnings, advantages, and challenges, as well as its integration with underlying email security protocols such as DKIM, SPF, and DMARC.
Technical foundations of ARC sealing
ARC sealing relies on the principle of creating an authentication chain for each email as it passes through various mail servers. The fundamental idea is to enable mail servers to validate the authenticity of the email throughout its journey, even as it traverses multiple relays.
In practice, when a mail server receives an email, it creates an Authenticated Received Chain (ARC) record that contains information about the email's authenticity, such as the results of SPF and DKIM checks performed by previous servers. This new ARC record is added to the email header before being passed on to the next server.
ARC Sealing Advantages & Drawbacks
Advantages
- Preservation of authenticity: ARC sealing ensures that the authentication information of the email is not altered during its transit through different mail servers, thereby bolstering trust in the email's authenticity.
- Reduction of false positives: By preserving email authentication throughout its journey, ARC sealing helps to reduce the risks of false positives, meaning legitimate emails being misidentified as spam or fraudulent.
- Improved deliverability: By enhancing the reliability of email authentication, ARC sealing can potentially enhance message deliverability by preventing them from being blocked or flagged as spam.
Drawbacks
- Implementation complexity: Setting up and managing ARC sealing can be complex, requiring a deep understanding of email security protocols as well as specific configurations on mail servers.
- Limited compatibility: While many email solutions support ARC sealing, such as LetzRelay-MX, its support is not universal, and there may be compatibility issues with certain platforms or existing configurations.
- Potential vulnerabilities: Like any technology, ARC sealing may have vulnerabilities or security flaws that could be exploited by malicious actors if ARC configurations are not properly implemented.
ARC sealing Potential vulnerabilities
It is important to note that these vulnerabilities below are not specific to ARC sealing and may also be present in other email security mechanisms. However, by understanding these potential vulnerabilities, organizations can take steps to enhance the security of their electronic communications and mitigate the risks associated with the use of ARC sealing:
- Replay of ARC records: A potential vulnerability of ARC sealing lies in the ability for an attacker to capture and replay valid ARC records. This could allow an attacker to impersonate a legitimate sender by reusing authentic ARC records for fraudulent emails.
- Modification of email header: Since ARC sealing relies on adding ARC records to the email header, any alteration of the email header could potentially compromise the authenticity of the ARC authentication chain. An attacker could modify the email header to remove or modify the ARC records, thereby compromising the validation of the email's authenticity.
- Injection attacks: Injection attacks, such as script injection or injection of malicious code, could also compromise the integrity of ARC sealing. If an attacker manages to inject malicious code into an email, this could potentially affect the ARC records or the results of SPF and DKIM checks, thereby compromising the email's security.
- Denial-of-Service (DDoS) attacks: Although less common, denial-of-service attacks against mail servers could also disrupt the ARC sealing process by preventing the transmission or verification of ARC records. Such an attack could make it difficult to validate the authenticity of emails, thereby compromising the security of electronic communication.
How to protect against ARC sealing potential vulnerabilities?
To guard against potential vulnerabilities associated with ARC sealing, organizations can implement several security measures and best practices. Here are some suggestions:
- Using strong cryptographic signatures: To guard against ARC record replay attacks and email header modification, it is essential to use a strong cryptographic signature for each ARC record. Robust hashing algorithms and secure encryption keys can enhance the security of ARC records.
- Rigorously validate ARC records: Mail servers should be configured to rigorously validate ARC records to detect any alteration or anomaly. Validation policies should be strict to ensure the integrity of the ARC authentication chain. In this regard, it is the main purpose of the new DARA standard, which is currently being experimented with by some email service solutions, such as Google, Fastmail, and of course LetzRelay-MX.
- Protect the email header: To prevent attacks aimed at modifying the email header, organizations must implement robust security measures to protect the integrity of the email header. This may include using encryption mechanisms, digital signatures, or strict access controls to prevent any unauthorized alterations.
- Monitor and detect suspicious activities: Organizations should implement intrusion detection and monitoring systems to detect any suspicious or abnormal activity related to ARC sealing. This may include monitoring mail server logs, analyzing traffic anomalies, and using threat detection technologies.
- Strengthen email server security: To guard against denial-of-service attacks and other attacks aimed at disrupting the ARC sealing process, organizations must strengthen the security of their email servers. This may include using firewalls, intrusion prevention systems, and capabilities for mitigating DDoS attacks.
Conclusion
ARC sealing is an advanced and essential technique in modern email management, offering significant advantages in terms of security and authenticity of electronic messages. While it presents challenges in terms of implementation complexity and compatibility, its integration with email security protocols such as DKIM, SPF, and DMARC enhances the reliability and trust in electronic communications.
Learn more on how LetzRelay-MX can help your organization be secured with Internet inbound emails.
